Only the Brave Review
By Rich Cline
Based on a genuinely moving true story, this film undercuts the realism by pushing its heroic machismo at every turn. It’s a well-made movie, with an above-average cast, and yet both the story and characters are neglected in the rush to honour the real-life men who risk their lives fighting wildfires. Thankfully, there are some strong, quiet moments along the way, and the story itself carries a proper emotional wallop.
It’s set in Prescott, Arizona, where Eric (Josh Brolin) is trying to get his firefighting team certified as hotshots, qualified to take on the big wildfires. Supported by fire chief Duane (Jeff Bridges), he builds a crew that includes loyal captain Jesse (James Badge Dale) and talented womaniser Mac (Taylor Kitsch), and he gives a second chance to Brendan (Miles Teller), a recovering addict who reminds Eric of himself. Then when the crew is certified as the Granite Mountain Hotshots, the pressures of work strain their relationships with their wives and children. Indeed, Eric’s strong-minded horse-trainer wife Amanda (Jennifer Connelly) is annoyed that she’s now seeing even less of him than before, but she supports his passion for the job.
Director Joseph Kozinski (Tron Legacy) directs the film with a rather relentless earnestness, clearly in reverent awe of these men. This allows for brief moments of raucous camaraderie, carefully controlled for a young teen audience, so the characters are interesting if never authentic. They feel more like overgrown Boy Scouts than earthy firefighters, and the overtones of heroism amongst them are a bit exhausting. Events unfold anecdotally, providing carefully concocted moments both in family lives and in the rather dull work of containing a wildfire. And this somewhat choppy approach prevents the film from building much momentum as it approaches its emotional climax, which is genuinely shattering.
Thankfully, all of the actors find small details that bring these people to life. Teller has the most well-developed character, and digs deeply into his emotional core. And a feisty Connelly adds an edgy kick to the film. At the centre of the story are the mentor relationships between Duane and Eric, then Eric and Brendan, and while this feels a little forced in its depiction of the legacy of the profession, it gives the film a nice sense of resonance. So it’s a bit frustrating that the story’s subtle power is drowned out by all of the tough-guy masculinity. And the movie would have been a lot more inspirational if the filmmakers didn’t try so hard.
Facts and Figures
Production compaines: Di Bonaventura Pictures, Black Label Media, Conde Nast Entertainment
-.com: 2.5 / 5
Cast & Crew
Director: Joseph Kosinski
Starring: Josh Brolin as Eric Marsh, Miles Teller as Brendan “Donut” McDonough, Jeff Bridges as Duane Steinbrink, Jennifer Connelly as Amanda Marsh, James Badge Dale as Jesse Steed, Taylor Kitsch as Christopher MacKenzie, Andie MacDowell as Marvel Steinbrink, Geoff Stults as Travis Turbyfill, Alex Russell as Andrew Ashcraft, Thad Luckinbill as Scott Norris, Ben Hardy as Wade Parker, Scott Haze as Clayton Whitted, Jake Picking as Anthony Rose, Scott Foxx as Travis Carter, Dylan Kenin as Robert Caldwell, Ryan Michael Busch as Dustin DeFord, Kenneth Miller as Sean Misner, Ryan Jason Cook as William Warneke, Brandon Bunch as Garret Zuppiger, Michael L. McNulty as Kevin Woyjeck, Nicholas Jenks as John Percin Jr., Sam Quinn as Grant McKee, Natalie Hall as Natalie Johnson, Howard Ferguson Jr. as Brian Ferguson, Rachel Singer as Brendan’s Mom, Ralph Alderman as Evaluator Hayes, Jenny Gabrielle as Desiree Steed, Brytnee Ratledge as Juliann Ashcraft, Pell James as Claire Caldwell, Jade Kammerman as Stephanie Turbyfill, Raleigh Cain as Nurse Nora, Lora Martinez-Cunningham as Dr. Ochoa, Matt Nolan as Medic in Helicopter, Lulu Jovovich as Kristi Whitted (uncredited)